Liberals face challenge of securing the vote while keeping leadership race accessible

Peter Zimonjic · CBC News

· Posted: Mar 06, 2025 4:00 AM EST | Last Updated: 5 hours ago

The problems immoderate registered Liberals are having with online voting successful the party's enactment contention shouldn't beryllium a astonishment and whitethorn adjacent beryllium a bully thing, accidental immoderate experts.

"You can't person a wide open, hardly astatine each verified process for selecting the premier curate of Canada," Christopher Cochrane, a governmental subject prof astatine the University of Toronto, told CBC News.

Cochrane points retired that erstwhile Prime Minister Justin Trudeau won the Liberal leadership successful 2013, it wasn't lone enactment members casting their ballots. A new people of supporters could registry to ballot without paying a rank fee.

Cochrane said that strategy made consciousness erstwhile the Liberals were the 3rd enactment successful the House of Commons and they needed to physique retired their list of supporters. But today, the menace of overseas interference combined with the information that the enactment contention volition prime the adjacent premier curate means the crippled has changed.

"It is absurd to person a massively open, escaped process, picking the premier curate of Canada. And the Liberals cognize that," Cochrane said.

Justice Marie-Josée Hogue, commissioner of the nationalist enquiry into overseas interference, warned that party enactment races were a vulnerability in her last study regarding the 2019 and 2021 national elections.

She issued a fig of recommendations, including the request to verify a enactment voter's citizenship oregon imperishable residency presumption and use the Canada Elections Act to enactment contests.

"It's apt that the enhanced information measures successful this contention is straight related to the overseas interference issues that person plagued Canadian elections successful the past respective years," Chris Alcantara, a governmental subject prof astatine Western University, told CBC News. 

The analyzable process

To ballot successful this race, registered Liberals indispensable get an physics elector ID, past verify that ID online. They past person to corroborate their presumption arsenic an eligible voter. After that they indispensable past corroborate their individuality utilizing the Canada Post Identity+ app oregon successful idiosyncratic astatine a participating station office. Once that is done, members tin formed their online vote.

But dozens of radical person present written to CBC News saying they person been incapable to get the process to work, peculiarly erstwhile it comes to the mobile app and in-person enactment to verify their identity.

"In programming, each measurement you adhd evidently creates a imaginable for an error, mistake oregon dysfunction and that's a multi-step, precise analyzable process," Cochrane said.

Mark Carney, the front-runner successful the race, has joked astir the process astatine antithetic run events, but has aligned with the enactment connected the contented of security. 

"We instrumentality information seriously," helium told a assemblage during a caller run stop. "We bash not privation immoderate accidental of overseas interference successful this election."

A spokesperson for the Liberal Party told CBC News that they could not remark connected individuals who whitethorn person written to CBC News with complaints.

"This is really the strategy working. If you're not capable to verify, there's a crushed you are not capable to verify," the spokesperson said.

"We privation to marque definite that we are putting connected a process that is unafraid and fair."

So far, much than 137,000 registered Liberals person been verified to ballot successful the contention and 115,000 person formed their ballot. Voting began Feb. 26 astatine 8 a.m. ET and closes March 9 astatine 3 p.m ET.

• This Sunday, Cross Country Checkup is asking: Who should beryllium the adjacent Liberal leader? Who bash you deliberation is beardown capable to instrumentality connected Donald Trump? Leave your remark here and we whitethorn work it oregon telephone you backmost for our amusement connected March 9th!

Stewart Prest, a lecturer successful governmental subject astatine the University of British Columbia, said Canadian governmental parties person the pugnacious task of trying to clasp a enactment predetermination that meets 2 related standards: forestall interference and don't disenfranchise voters.

"Politically speaking it's the much unsafe disapproval that determination are those who are ineligible to ballot who are taking portion successful the electoral process," Prest told CBC News.

"There is simply a capable nationalist bully successful ensuring that governmental parties are choosing leaders reliably and successful a mode that is escaped of interference but besides maximizes accessibility of the vote."

Building a stronger process

These experts accidental radical volition progressively conflict to usage evolving technologies and governmental parties request to marque definite they are capable to guarantee they tin tally just elections. 

Prest said parties whitethorn beryllium much consenting to instrumentality disapproval that their voting was overly secure, disenfranchising immoderate voters, than for letting unqualified radical vote. But helium argues that presumption is not sustainable.

"Parties are yet going to request to find ways to physique enactment voting processes that either lucifer Elections Canada standards oregon so are built successful co-operation with Elections Canada, due to the fact that that is the golden modular for the country," helium said. 

Cochrane says that the vexation immoderate registered Liberals are feeling was inevitable, but the results of this contention volition apt fulfill the party. 

"As agelong arsenic their diehard supporters are the ones that are coming retired and incurring each of those costs to ballot for their candidate, they volition astir apt extremity up with the person that the basal wants," Cochrane said.