Is Pierre Poilievre too 'in sync' with Donald Trump?

The astir arguable connection of the national predetermination truthful acold was uttered earlier the run adjacent started — not by a national politician, but the premier of Alberta.

In an interrogation taped connected March 8 with a right-wing American media outlet, Danielle Smith said that, portion determination would ever beryllium disagreements, Conservative Leader Pierre Poilievre would beryllium "very overmuch successful sync with … the caller absorption successful America" and that Canada and the United States would "have a large relationship" for arsenic agelong arsenic Poilievre and Donald Trump were successful office.

"If we bash person Pierre arsenic our premier minister, past I deliberation there's a fig of things that we could bash together," Smith said. "Pierre believes successful development, helium believes successful low-cost energy, helium believes that we request to person debased taxes, doesn't judge successful immoderate of the woke worldly that we've seen taking implicit our authorities for the past 5 years."

Liberals have, for months, been trying to nexus Poilievre and Trump, either substantively oregon stylistically — Chrystia Freeland, for instance, utilized the word "maple syrup MAGA" to picture the Conservatives past fall. And truthful Smith's comments — which lone came to wider attraction past play — were a acquisition to the governing party.

Standing successful beforehand of Rideau Hall connected Sunday, Mark Carney said Canadians would person to determine "whether they privation a authorities that is unifying, lasting up for Canada and is taking focused enactment to physique a amended economy" oregon whether they "want part and Americanism." 

"That's what Mr. Poilievre seems to beryllium offering," Carney said. "Just endorsed by the premier of Alberta."

WATCH | Poilievre says Trump needs to 'knock it off': 

Last period erstwhile Trump himself said that Poilievre was "not MAGA" (referring to his Make America Great Again movement), Poilievre was speedy to enactment the comment. But the Conservative person has avoided offering a nonstop rebuttal of Smith's analysis.

"People are escaped to marque their ain comments," helium said connected Monday, earlier arguing that helium would contiguous the strongest effect to Trump's threats.

As precocious arsenic a fewer months ago, immoderate similarities betwixt Poilievre and Trump mightiness not person seemed to matter. It astatine slightest didn't look that the Conservative leader's large populism and assertive tactics were imperilling the Conservative Party's chances of forming government.

But this past Wednesday night, a Conservative strategist made the aforesaid examination that Smith did — only this clip arsenic a lament.

"He looks excessively overmuch similar Trump. He sounds excessively overmuch similar Trump. He uses the lexicon of Trump," Kory Teneycke, who managed the Ontario Progressive Conservative Party's run earlier this year, told an assemblage successful Toronto.

Canadian politicians accusing each different of importing "American-style" authorities is thing new. But to immoderate grade oregon another, this national predetermination is really astir the American president. And Trump is simply a precise antithetic benignant of governmental figure.

The similarities and differences

As people, Trump and Poilievre person immoderate evident differences.

But 55 per cent of respondents to a caller survey by Abacus Data said they thought Poilievre would person either powerfully oregon somewhat supported Trump successful the past American statesmanlike election.And it's not hard to spot however Canadians mightiness person travel to that decision (above and beyond simply connecting Canadian Conservatives with U.S. Republicans).

"Trump and Poilievre are chiefly akin erstwhile it comes to the populist quality of their connection styles," says Emily Laxer, manager of the Observatory of Populism successful Canada astatine York University. "Both question popularity and votes by framing authorities arsenic a zero-sum conflict betwixt corrupt, self-interested elites and a hard-working, embattled people."

Poilievre initially embraced the self-described "Freedom Convoy" and helium has vowed to decision the "gatekeepers" who are seemingly lasting successful the mode of Canadians prospering. He has said he'd occurrence the politician of the Bank of Canada, defund the CBC and invoke the notwithstanding clause to override judicial rulings against his attempts to enforce harsher sentences connected those convicted of committing crimes.

One of Poilievre's slogans — "Canada First" — echoes Trump's ain speech of putting "America first." He uses "woke" arsenic an all-purpose pejorative and says helium is connected the broadside of "common sense." He has toyed with conspiracy theories and said helium would prohibition his ministers from attending the World Economic Forum.

Poilievre thrives connected struggle and has attacked large media outlets and accused them of being successful league with the Liberal government. He besides took to describing Liberal policies arsenic "wacko" (after being ejected from the House of Commons for utilizing that connection to picture the premier minister).

As Laxer notes, Poilievre and Trump stock a fondness for derisive nicknames ("Trust Fund Trudeau," "Sellout Singh," "Carbon Tax Carney"). Stewart Prest, a lecturer successful governmental subject astatine the University of British Columbia, notes that some Poilievre and Trump person promoted the thought of nationalist restoration. 

(Poilievre has besides accused Justin Trudeau of pushing a "radical ideology" connected sex and has antecedently promised to withhold national backing from universities that bash not adequately uphold state of code — 2 issues that person animated Republican authorities successful the United States.)

In the aboriginal days of this campaign, Poilievre seemed to privation to recalibrate his nationalist presentation. He was, for instance, noticeably cordial with reporters connected Sunday. But helium besides accused the Liberals of promoting a "radical, post-national, borderless and globalist ideology." 

WATCH | Trump's car tariffs upend predetermination campaign: 

"I deliberation 1 mode to deliberation astir the halfway of the similarity is that they some people framework authorities successful presumption that we mightiness picture arsenic right-of-centre populist," Prest says. "And truthful they some aquatics successful that aforesaid governmental sea, if you like."

There are nevertheless important differences betwixt Poilievre and Trump.

Poilievre is not moving a nativist run against immigration, nor has helium refused to admit the results of past predetermination oregon incited a convulsive insurrection (though Poilievre did precocious question the turnout successful the Liberal enactment race). He has not denied the world of clime change, nor is helium threatening to rip up Canada's free-trade deals oregon wantonness Ukraine.

The questions raised by Smith's comments

Smith's connection that Poilievre is "in sync" with "the caller absorption successful America" mightiness rise a fewer questions for the Conservative leader.

While Poilievre has argued helium would contiguous the strongest effect to Trump due to the fact that Liberal policies person weakened the country, Liberals person been suggesting that Poilievre's similarities with Trump mean helium won't beryllium capable to basal up to the American president. And portion Poilievre has pointed to Trump's assertion that helium would alternatively negociate with a Liberal, Smith's comments arguably bolster the Liberal view. 

On a larger scale, Smith's comments could rise the question of whether Poilievre mightiness beryllium much unfastened to a greater level of continued integration with the United States than Carney's Liberals would beryllium — and the 2 leaders' comments this week hint astatine differing views connected that question. 

"We cannot spend to person immoderate person who goes retired determination and deliberately undermines the assurance successful institutions," Charest said. "Conservatives bash not bash that."

Poilievre could conceivably effort to explain precisely however helium differs from Trump and which parts of Trumpism he rejects. But immoderate information of Conservative voters whitethorn inactive consciousness positively toward Trump — 31 per cent of Conservative supporters had a affirmative content of the president when Abacus Data surveyed Canadians successful February, though David Coletto of Abacus says caller polling to beryllium published this play volition amusement that fig has dropped to 22 per cent.

Ultimately, Poilievre mightiness beryllium judged connected his own words, merits and record, careless of comparisons. 

Six months ago, Poilievre seemed to beryllium riding a populist question to the premier minister's office. And portion helium inactive mightiness triumph power, close present that question is being undercut by the spectre and world of the world's astir almighty populist.

LISTEN | Poilievre's Trump problem: