A proposed 10-storey apartment has one St. John's resident frustrated with the city

Elizabeth Whitten · CBC News

· Posted: Mar 31, 2025 3:01 PM EDT | Last Updated: 6 hours ago

A projected 10-storey flat gathering successful St. John's has 1 nonmigratory disquieted that the metropolis isn't pursuing its ain rules.

KMK Capital wants to physique a 107-unit flat gathering astatine 34 New Cove Road, the tract of the erstwhile MAX recreation facility.

Mary Fearon says she had "mixed feelings" erstwhile she heard metropolis assembly voted to exempt the task from the step-back requirement, which is meant to mitigate the interaction of wind, shadiness and height.

"Those rules and regulations and policies and procedures are successful spot to guarantee that we're gathering the needs of who [the] metropolis works for, which are the assemblage members, and the metropolis arsenic a whole, right? Not conscionable developers," she told CBC Radio's The St. John's Morning Show.

Fearon feels the metropolis didn't travel its ain municipal program to marque definite caller builds are due to the neighbourhood. 

She wants KMK to trim its proposal's tallness and is disquieted astir further postulation successful the area.

"There's tons of disposable spaces successful St. John's close present wherever lodging could beryllium built," said Fearon.

CBC News has asked KMK for comment.

Building has changed

But Mayor Danny Breen says the metropolis has a "robust" engagement process implicit proposals, and assembly considers those arguments and different accusation erstwhile it makes decisions.

"In this case, this is simply a task that I've concluded that's successful a precise bully determination for an flat building," said Breen.

He pointed to its proximity walking trails and amenities similar market stories and nationalist transit, arsenic good arsenic its impacts to traffic.

Breen said the metropolis looked astatine the interaction of the set-back and determined determination volition beryllium a shadiness successful the evening that volition spell implicit the instrumentality bureau crossed the thoroughfare and to the cemetery.

"That was the biggest interaction from not having a set-back. So assembly decided not to necessitate the set-back," helium said.

He added the metropolis tin waive requirements if determination is simply a coagulated crushed given, which, helium said, isn't done lightly.

If assembly had determined a set-back was required, Breen said it would person resulted successful KMK eliminating respective flat units.

"That would person changed the economics of the building," helium said, adding that could mean the remaining units are much costly to rent.

"One happening that I deliberation radical should recognize is that the economics of gathering these buildings is changing. It's getting very, precise costly and determination is going to beryllium a request to person higher buildings."

Breen said determination are astir 2,000 lodging units currently in assorted stages of the city's exertion process.

Download our free CBC News app to motion up for propulsion alerts for CBC Newfoundland and Labrador. Sign up for our daily headlines newsletter here. Click here to sojourn our landing page.